When Noelia Voigt, the reigning Miss USA, decided to resign from her prestigious role, she stated on Instagram that her decision was influenced by her mental health needs and expressed her gratitude for the experiences she had gained. “As individuals, we grow through experiencing different things in life that lead us to learning more about ourselves,” she explained.
However, a confidential resignation letter written by Ms. Voigt to the Miss USA leadership and the Miss Universe Organization, which The New York Times obtained, revealed a troubling situation. In this eight-page document, Ms. Voigt described the working environment at the Miss USA Organization as toxic. She pointed out that the issues ranged from poor management to serious accusations of bullying and harassment. Furthermore, she mentioned that the organization had delayed delivering her prize winnings, adding to her grievances.
The Miss USA Organization did not respond to these allegations when asked for comment by The New York Times.
The situation escalated as Ms. Voigt’s decision to resign prompted similar actions from others. UmaSofia Srivastava, who held the title of Miss Teen USA, and Arianna Lemus, who represented Colorado at Miss USA in 2023, also stepped down. Ms. Lemus, particularly moved by Ms. Voigt’s public post, mentioned in an interview, “That was a call to help,” signaling her solidarity.
These resignations have sparked broader discussions and speculation about the legal constraints that might prevent winners from speaking out against the Miss USA Organization. Many former competitors rallied around Ms. Voigt, demanding her release from any nondisclosure agreements that could be silencing her.
In her resignation letter, Ms. Voigt recounted an unsettling experience of sexual harassment at a Christmas parade in Sarasota, Florida. She reported that a driver had made inappropriate comments towards her, and she felt unsupported by the organization when she reported the incident.
The stress and negative environment took a severe toll on Ms. Voigt’s health, leading to anxiety, heart palpitations, significant weight loss, sleep disturbances, and even hair loss.
Intriguingly, some people noticed that the initial letters of each sentence in her Instagram resignation post spelled out “I AM SILENCED.” This has been interpreted as a hidden message indicating her frustration and inability to speak openly about her experiences.
Shortly after Ms. Voigt’s announcement, Ms. Srivastava also resigned from her position as Miss Teen USA. She expressed that her personal values no longer aligned with the organization’s direction. Her statement included a poignant quote from Friedrich Nietzsche: “There are no beautiful surfaces without a terrible depth.”
Laylah Rose, the president and chief executive of the Miss USA Organization, acknowledged the resignations and expressed a desire to take constructive steps forward. “Our all-encompassing goal at Miss USA is to celebrate and empower women,” Ms. Rose stated, affirming her commitment to taking the allegations seriously.
Both Ms. Srivastava and Ms. Voigt, through a representative, declined to comment further, citing their nondisclosure agreements. The 2023 Miss USA contract, as reported, restricts signees from disclosing any information related to the organization while employed.
In response to the unfolding events, several of Ms. Voigt’s fellow competitors from the 2023 Miss USA pageant united to demand the organization release her from any such agreements. This collective action was initially discussed in a group chat and solidified during a Zoom call among the participants.
Juliana Morehouse, a competitor from Maine, shared that the women were deeply affected by Ms. Voigt’s resignation and wanted to support her openly. Meanwhile, Claudia Michelle Engelhardt, the former social media director for Miss USA who also resigned, criticized the organization for pressuring participants into signing contracts without adequate time or legal advice. She argued that the contracts were unfairly coercive.
Despite these challenges, Ms. Morehouse noted that her own experiences with Miss USA were positive but emphasized the importance of speaking out to ensure fair treatment for all participants in the future.
Ms. Lemus highlighted the irony of the situation, noting the discrepancy between the organization’s message of women’s empowerment and the reality of its operations.
This article is based on the following article:
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/05/10/style/miss-usa-resigns-pageant-letter.html
Background Information
By understanding these elements, readers can better appreciate the complexities and challenges that can exist behind the glamorous facade of beauty pageants, as well as the legal and personal aspects involved in such high-profile roles.
What is a Beauty Pageant?
A beauty pageant is a competition that often involves contestants, typically women, competing in various activities such as swimsuit, evening wear, talent, and interview segments. Participants are judged not only on their physical appearance but also on other attributes like talent, intelligence, and answers to judges’ questions. The purpose of these contests varies, ranging from promoting social causes to showcasing beauty and fashion.
Miss USA and Miss Universe Organizations
The Miss USA and Miss Universe are two of the most famous beauty pageants globally. Miss USA contestants are typically women between the ages of 18 and 28 who compete to represent their state. The winner of Miss USA goes on to compete in the Miss Universe pageant, which includes winners from many countries around the world.
These organizations claim to provide opportunities for women to advance their careers, personal and humanitarian goals, and to empower them to achieve their personal and professional goals.
The Role and Impact of Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs)
Non-disclosure agreements are legal contracts that restrict the parties’ ability to share certain information with others. In the context of beauty pageants like Miss USA, NDAs are often used to prevent contestants from publicly discussing certain details about the organization or their experiences within the pageant. This can include personal experiences or internal operations that might reflect negatively on the organization.
These agreements are intended to protect the privacy and proprietary information of the organization but can sometimes be seen as a way to silence participants from speaking about negative experiences or issues within the organization.
Importance of Understanding Mental Health
The article mentions the impact of the experience on Noelia Voigt’s mental health, including anxiety and other physical symptoms. Understanding mental health is crucial, as it refers to our emotional, psychological, and social well-being. It affects how we think, feel, and act, especially in handling stress, relating to others, and making choices. In high-pressure environments like beauty pageants, mental health awareness is essential for recognizing the signs of stress and the importance of supportive measures for participants.
Debate/Essay Questions
- Should beauty pageants like Miss USA have the power to enforce non-disclosure agreements on their contestants?
- Do beauty pageants do more harm than good in promoting women’s empowerment?
Please subscribe to Insight Fortnight, our biweekly newsletter!