On Tuesday, the U.S. House of Representatives narrowly passed a budget resolution that lays the foundation for President Donald Trump’s economic agenda. With a vote of 217 to 215, the bill represents a significant victory for House Speaker Mike Johnson and the Republican leadership, despite facing resistance from both Democrats and some Republicans.
The budget resolution is a key step toward approving a broader financial plan that includes $4.5 trillion in tax cuts while reducing federal spending by $2 trillion over the next decade. This measure also increases funding for defense and border security by about $300 billion. The tax cuts, largely an extension of those enacted in 2017, were originally set to expire but are now being pushed forward under the new plan. However, lawmakers are still debating which specific taxes should be reduced and how spending cuts will be applied.
A Close and Controversial Vote
The passage of the bill was uncertain until the last moment. Speaker Johnson faced significant challenges in securing votes from within his own party, as the Republican majority in the House is slim. The resolution passed with no Democratic support, and one Republican, Representative Thomas Massie of Kentucky, voted against it.
Some conservative Republicans wanted even deeper spending cuts, arguing that the proposed reductions were not enough to balance the budget. Others, including moderates, were concerned that the planned cuts—especially those affecting Medicaid and food assistance programs—would harm their constituents. The House leadership initially announced that the vote would not happen that evening due to the lack of support. However, in a dramatic reversal, Speaker Johnson suddenly recalled lawmakers to the chamber and pushed the vote through.
Johnson had previously urged lawmakers to unite behind the plan, emphasizing its importance for advancing Trump’s economic policies. He told an audience before the vote that the budget resolution was the necessary first step toward implementing Trump’s “full agenda” and that it was critical to pass the bill without delay.
Key Features of the Budget Plan
The budget resolution does not outline specific program cuts but instead directs congressional committees to propose spending reductions in various areas. The Energy and Commerce Committee, which oversees Medicaid, is expected to recommend $880 billion in cuts. Some Republicans worry that such deep reductions would be difficult to achieve without significantly cutting healthcare services for low-income Americans. Other committees, such as the Agriculture Committee, have been instructed to identify $230 billion in savings, which could impact food assistance programs.
Despite concerns over Medicaid cuts, some Republicans insisted that the plan would not eliminate healthcare for vulnerable populations. Speaker Johnson reassured lawmakers that spending reductions would come from eliminating fraud and waste rather than removing benefits for eligible individuals. However, Democrats and some advocacy groups argue that such deep budget reductions will inevitably lead to fewer services for millions of Americans.
In addition to spending cuts, the resolution paves the way for extending the tax policies enacted under Trump’s first term. Republicans say that if these tax cuts are not renewed, millions of Americans will see higher tax bills when they expire. However, Democrats argue that these tax breaks primarily benefit wealthy individuals and corporations, while middle- and lower-income families will bear the burden of spending cuts.
Debate and Opposition
The resolution has sparked heated debate between Republicans and Democrats. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries strongly opposed the plan, calling it “the largest Medicaid cut in American history” and a “betrayal” of working-class families. During a press conference, he stood alongside Americans who depend on Medicaid and other federal programs, arguing that the Republican plan would harm millions of people.
Democrats also warned that the budget framework would increase the national deficit, as the cost of the tax cuts outweighs the planned spending reductions. Some lawmakers pointed out that while the bill aims to cut $2 trillion in spending, the overall cost of the tax breaks would be at least $4.5 trillion, potentially adding to the country’s $36 trillion debt.
Even among Republicans, there was division over the resolution. Fiscal conservatives worried that the tax cuts would worsen the deficit, while some moderates feared that reducing government assistance programs would harm their voters. Representative Victoria Spartz of Indiana initially opposed the bill over concerns that it would not sufficiently address the deficit. However, she changed her position after receiving a “personal commitment” from Trump to “save healthcare and make it better.”
Next Steps
Passing the budget resolution in the House is just the first step in a long legislative process. The Senate must now consider its own version of the budget, which differs from the House’s proposal. Senate Republicans have already passed a smaller $340 billion budget framework that focuses on border security and defense spending but does not include tax cuts.
The two chambers must reconcile their differences before a final bill can be sent to Trump for approval. Additionally, lawmakers are facing another deadline: a separate deal is needed to prevent a government shutdown, as federal funding is set to expire on March 14. This could further complicate negotiations.
Speaker Johnson and Republican leaders will now need to build support within their party while also dealing with opposition from Democrats. The final details of the budget plan will be debated in committees over the coming weeks, with the outcome likely shaping government funding, taxes, and public services for years to come.
This article is based on the following articles:
Background Information
How the U.S. Government Budget Works
The United States government spends money on various programs and services, including defense, healthcare, infrastructure, and social welfare programs like Medicaid and food assistance. To pay for these expenses, the government collects revenue mainly through taxes on income, businesses, and imports.
However, sometimes the government spends more money than it collects in taxes. When this happens, it creates a budget deficit, which means the government must borrow money to cover the difference. Over time, these deficits add up to what is called the national debt, which is the total amount of money the government owes to lenders, including foreign governments, banks, and private investors.
Each year, Congress must pass a budget that sets limits on how much the government can spend and how it will collect revenue. The budget is created through a process involving both the House of Representatives and the Senate. When the two chambers pass different versions of the budget, they must negotiate and agree on a final version before it becomes law.
What is a Budget Resolution?
A budget resolution is not an actual law but rather a guide that outlines the government’s financial plans. It sets goals for spending, tax policy, and deficits over a certain period (usually 10 years). While the resolution itself does not decide where every dollar goes, it instructs congressional committees on how much they need to cut or allocate for different areas like healthcare, defense, and education.
Budget resolutions are important because they influence how much funding is available for government programs. They can also determine whether taxes will go up or down. This means that budget resolutions have a direct impact on people’s lives, affecting services like healthcare, education, and infrastructure.
What Are Tax Cuts, and Why Do They Matter?
A tax cut is when the government reduces the amount of taxes people and businesses must pay. Tax cuts can be popular because they allow individuals and companies to keep more of their earnings. However, they also mean the government collects less revenue, which can lead to higher deficits unless spending is reduced to match the lost income.
The tax cuts that the House resolution seeks to extend were originally introduced in 2017 during Trump’s first term. These cuts were designed to lower taxes for individuals and businesses, but critics argue that they mainly benefited wealthy Americans and large corporations. Supporters, on the other hand, believe that lower taxes encourage economic growth by giving people and businesses more money to invest and spend.
Because the 2017 tax cuts were set to expire, Congress must decide whether to renew them. If they are not extended, taxes will go up for many Americans. However, extending them without reducing spending in other areas could increase the national debt.
Why Do Spending Cuts Cause Debate?
When the government decides to cut spending, it often affects public services such as healthcare, education, transportation, and social programs. Some lawmakers believe that reducing spending is necessary to prevent the government from borrowing too much money and increasing the national debt. Others argue that spending cuts can harm low-income and middle-class families by reducing access to important services.
For example, one of the major concerns in the budget resolution is the potential impact on Medicaid, a government program that provides healthcare to low-income individuals, children, pregnant women, and people with disabilities. The resolution instructs committees to cut $880 billion, which could lead to significant reductions in Medicaid funding. Supporters of the cuts argue that they will come from eliminating waste and fraud rather than cutting benefits. Opponents worry that fewer people will be able to access affordable healthcare.
Another area facing possible cuts is food assistance programs, such as the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), which helps millions of low-income families afford groceries. Reducing funding for SNAP could mean that fewer families receive food assistance, which could lead to increased food insecurity.
The Role of the President and Congress in Passing a Budget
In the United States, the president does not have the power to create a budget alone. Instead, Congress plays a crucial role in deciding how money is allocated. The president can suggest a budget plan, but it is up to lawmakers in the House and Senate to approve or reject it.
Once Congress passes a budget resolution, committees in both chambers must draft bills that outline specific spending and tax policies. These bills are debated and voted on before they are sent to the president for approval. If both chambers agree on a final version and the president signs it, it becomes law. If the two chambers cannot agree or the president vetoes the bill, the government may face a shutdown, where many federal agencies temporarily stop operating due to a lack of funding.
What is the Reconciliation Process?
One reason this budget resolution is important is that it allows Republicans to use a process called budget reconciliation. This is a special rule in Congress that allows certain budget-related bills to pass with a simple majority in the Senate, instead of needing 60 votes to overcome a filibuster.
This means that if Republicans can agree on a final budget package, they can pass it without needing Democratic support in the Senate. However, since the party is divided on certain spending cuts, reaching an agreement may still be difficult.
Why Are Some Republicans Divided?
Although the Republican Party controls the House and Senate, not all members agree on the budget resolution. Some Republicans, especially fiscal conservatives, are concerned that the tax cuts will increase the national debt because the spending reductions are not large enough to cover the cost. Others worry that the spending cuts will go too far and hurt their constituents, particularly those who rely on Medicaid and food assistance programs.
Because Speaker Mike Johnson has only a small Republican majority in the House, he had to convince nearly every member of his party to support the bill. This was a challenge, as some Republicans refused to vote for it unless they received guarantees that Medicaid would not be cut too much.
The Senate’s Role and What Happens Next
Although the House has passed this budget resolution, the Senate must now decide on its own version. The Senate has already passed a different budget framework that does not include tax cuts, which means the two chambers will need to negotiate a compromise.
Additionally, Congress is facing another urgent issue—a government funding deadline on March 14. If lawmakers do not reach an agreement on government spending by then, the country could experience a government shutdown, where many federal agencies and services temporarily close due to a lack of funding.
The final budget bill will need to pass both the House and Senate before it is sent to President Trump for approval. Over the next few weeks, lawmakers will debate the details, and the outcome will affect government funding, taxes, and public programs for years to come.
Debate/Essay Questions
- Should Congress reduce funding for Medicaid and food assistance programs to lower government spending?
- How should Congress decide which government programs to cut and which to keep?
- Are there better ways to reduce wasteful government spending without cutting important programs? If so, what are they?
Please subscribe to Insight Fortnight, our biweekly newsletter!