Recently, comedian Jerry Seinfeld shared his views on contemporary television and its humor—or lack thereof—during an interview while promoting his new movie about the invention of the Pop-Tart. According to Seinfeld, a major reason for the perceived decline in TV comedy is the influence of political correctness and what he describes as the extreme left. This is a sentiment he shares with other comedians who have been voicing similar concerns for about a decade.
In his critique, Seinfeld aligns with a broader argument that has been made frequently in recent years: that political correctness is to blame for various societal issues. This line of reasoning isn’t unique to Seinfeld; it’s been echoed by various public figures across different contexts.
For example, former President Donald Trump has often criticized political correctness, notably when he called for a “total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States.” Author Anne Rice also lamented what she saw as a culture of excessive sensitivity when she came to the defense of chef Paula Deen, who had admitted to using racially offensive language. Similarly, Jackson Miller, a former Virginia legislator and member of the “Redskins Pride Caucus,” described the controversy over the Washington Football Team’s name as an example of “political correctness on overdrive.”
These comments share a common thread: they tend to sidestep the underlying reasons why certain jokes, remarks, or policies might be offensive or harmful. Instead, they focus on criticizing the type of person who would object to such things, often labeling them as overly sensitive or intolerant.
The term “politically correct” itself is quite versatile, and its definition seems to expand to encompass a variety of behaviors and actions depending on who is using it. Whether it involves capitalizing the word “Indigenous,” refraining from laughing at a joke that targets transgender people, or challenging racist practices in academic settings, accusations of political correctness can dismiss genuine concerns as mere overreactions.
Yet, as comedian Gary Gulman points out, “…the people who are saying you ‘can’t say anything,’ are saying everything on Netflix for $20 million a whack.” For instance, Seinfeld himself continues to work on high-profile projects, such as his movie about Pop-Tarts, which suggests that the constraints of political correctness might not be as limiting as some claim.
This observation raises a question: If those who are most vocal about the limitations imposed by political correctness are still thriving in their careers, who really is being overly sensitive?
This article is based on the following article:
https://www.npr.org/sections/codeswitch/2024/05/04/1249034786/jerry-seinfeld-comedy-politics
Background Information
Understanding these elements can help readers see why the article’s subject matter is significant and why it provokes strong opinions on both sides of the political and cultural spectrum.
- Jerry Seinfeld and His Influence: Jerry Seinfeld is an American stand-up comedian, actor, writer, and producer best known for his sitcom “Seinfeld,” which aired from 1989 to 1998. The show was hugely popular and is still celebrated for its unique take on everyday life’s trivialities, earning Seinfeld a significant place in American pop culture.
- Political Correctness (PC): This term refers to the avoidance of language and actions that could be offensive to others, particularly regarding race, gender, and other personal attributes. It’s a concept that aims to protect minority groups from discrimination and promote inclusivity, but it has also been criticized for limiting free speech and suppressing different viewpoints.
- Left-Wing Politics: In the article, Seinfeld mentions the “extreme left.” This term generally refers to the more progressive or liberal segment of the political spectrum, which emphasizes equality, social justice, and protection for marginalized groups. Critics sometimes argue that extreme left policies can be overly restrictive regarding what is acceptable in public discourse.
- Pop-Tarts and Cultural Commentary: The reference to a movie about the invention of the Pop-Tart (a popular toaster pastry) might seem trivial, but it represents how everyday items can be subjects of cultural commentary. Such a topic might be chosen for its nostalgic value or its representation of innovation and American consumer culture.
- Comedians on Censorship: Many comedians, including Seinfeld, argue that comedy is an area where free speech is essential and that political correctness can stifle their ability to joke freely. This debate touches on the broader issue of whether there should be limits to humor, especially if it risks offending or harming others.
- High-Profile Cases Cited: The article mentions several public figures:
- Donald Trump: Former President known for his controversial statements and policies, particularly concerning immigration and race.
- Anne Rice: An author who defended another public figure’s use of racially insensitive language.
- Paula Deen: A celebrity chef who faced public backlash after admitting to using racially offensive language.
- Jackson Miller and the Redskins Pride Caucus: This refers to debates around the name of the Washington Football Team (formerly known as the Redskins), which many considered a racial slur against Native Americans.
Debate/Essay Questions
- Is political correctness necessary in comedy, or does it restrict the creative freedom of comedians?
- Does the concept of political correctness serve more as a tool for inclusivity or as a form of censorship?
- Can humor be considered truly ‘harmless,’ or is there always a potential for jokes to cause harm?
Please subscribe to Insight Fortnight, our biweekly newsletter!