Background and Claims:
Salem Media Group, a conservative media company, has issued an apology to Mark Andrews, a Georgia man falsely depicted in the film “2000 Mules” as committing election fraud. The film, released in 2022 and co-produced by Salem Media Group, was directed by Dinesh D’Souza. It claimed that Democrats conspired with nonprofit groups to rig the 2020 election in favor of President Joe Biden by using “mules” who stuffed ballot boxes in swing states. The documentary, which quickly garnered a significant following and grossed over $10 million in its first two weeks, presented surveillance footage of Andrews placing ballots into a drop box near Atlanta, accompanied by D’Souza’s voice-over alleging the action was a crime and the votes were fraudulent.
Details of the Accusation:
The footage of Andrews, although blurred in the film, was used in unblurred form to promote the movie on various conservative news platforms, including Tucker Carlson’s former show on Fox News and a show hosted by Charlie Kirk. This led to Andrews being falsely accused of illegal voting. D’Souza, along with Salem Media and individuals associated with the election-monitoring group True the Vote, faced a defamation lawsuit filed by Andrews in October 2022. The Georgia Bureau of Investigation found that Andrews had committed no crime, as he had legally deposited ballots for himself and several family members.
Apology and Retractions:
In response to the lawsuit and subsequent investigation findings, Salem Media Group issued a public apology to Andrews and his family. They stated, “It was never our intent that the publication of the ‘2000 Mules’ film and book would harm Mr. Andrews. We apologize for the hurt the inclusion of Mr. Andrews’s image in the movie, book, and promotional materials have caused Mr. Andrews and his family.” The company also removed the film from its platforms and ceased further distribution of both the film and its companion book.
Widespread Misinformation and Legal Proceedings:
Despite its widespread debunking, “2000 Mules” became a touchstone for those convinced of a stolen 2020 election. Former President Donald Trump called it “the greatest and most impactful documentary of our time.” Advocacy groups inspired by the film’s claims took actions such as staking out ballot boxes and warning voters against early voting. The film’s allegations were based on data from True the Vote, which used cell phone location data to assert that ballot “mules” repeatedly approached drop boxes and participated in Black Lives Matter protests. These claims, however, were disproven by investigations, including one by Arizona’s attorney general, who referred True the Vote to federal authorities for further scrutiny.
Admissions of False Claims:
Some of the film’s staunchest promoters, including Rudolph W. Giuliani, who attended a screening at Mar-a-Lago, President Trump’s residence in Palm Beach, Florida, and Fox News, which aired several segments about the film, later admitted that they had promoted falsehoods about the election. In February, a lawyer for True the Vote told a Georgia court that it had no evidence to support its allegations of election fraud in the state. Despite these admissions, a poll conducted last August by CNN found that more than two-thirds of Republican voters did not believe that President Biden had won fairly.
Impact on Andrews:
Andrews’s defamation lawsuit highlighted the personal and familial distress caused by the film’s false accusations. According to the lawsuit, Andrews and his family faced violent threats and lived in fear of being wrongly accused again. The suit was supported by the nonprofit group Protect Democracy, which has also assisted other election-related defamation cases. Salem Media settled the lawsuit with Andrews for an undisclosed, significant amount, but the legal battle continues as the case progresses through the court system.
Industry Response and Further Developments:
The controversy around “2000 Mules” has led to broader discussions about the responsibilities of media companies in disseminating information. True the Vote distanced itself from the book version of the film, stating it had no participation or knowledge of its contents, particularly concerning specific allegations against nonprofit groups. The book was subsequently recalled and revised to omit several allegations. Despite these actions, many Americans remain convinced of the documentary’s claims, illustrating the enduring impact of election-related misinformation.
This article is based on the following articles:
https://apnews.com/article/2000-mules-film-apology-f1c2de96f17e72241761b4e6deaee5cb
Background Information
1. Overview of the 2020 Presidential Election: The 2020 United States presidential election was held on November 3, 2020. The main candidates were the incumbent Republican President Donald Trump and the Democratic former Vice President Joe Biden. Joe Biden won the election with 306 electoral votes to Trump’s 232. However, Trump and many of his supporters claimed that the election was marred by widespread voter fraud, despite multiple investigations and court rulings finding no evidence to support these claims.
2. Voter Fraud Allegations: Voter fraud refers to illegal interference with the election process, such as tampering with ballots or voter registration records. In the context of the 2020 election, these allegations included claims of dead people voting, non-citizens voting, and fraudulent ballots being submitted. These claims have been widely debunked by election officials, independent audits, and courts across the country.
3. The Film ‘2000 Mules’: “2000 Mules” is a documentary film released in 2022, directed by conservative commentator Dinesh D’Souza. The film alleges that the 2020 election was stolen from Donald Trump through a coordinated effort involving so-called “mules” who illegally collected and delivered ballots in swing states. The film uses surveillance footage and cell phone location data to support its claims. However, these claims have been thoroughly investigated and debunked by various authorities.
4. Key Players:
- Dinesh D’Souza: A conservative political commentator, author, and filmmaker known for his controversial documentaries and books. He directed and narrated “2000 Mules.”
- True the Vote: A Texas-based nonprofit organization that describes its mission as protecting election integrity. It provided much of the data used in “2000 Mules.”
- Salem Media Group: A conservative media company that co-produced and distributed the film. It operates numerous radio stations, websites, and publications.
- Mark Andrews: A Georgia man who was falsely depicted in the film as committing election fraud by illegally depositing ballots. Investigations found that Andrews had legally submitted ballots for himself and his family members.
5. Defamation and Legal Context: Defamation is the act of making false statements about a person that can harm their reputation. Mark Andrews sued Dinesh D’Souza, Salem Media Group, and individuals associated with True the Vote for defamation after being wrongly portrayed in the film. The Georgia Bureau of Investigation cleared Andrews of any wrongdoing, confirming that he legally submitted the ballots.
6. Impact of the Film: Despite being debunked, “2000 Mules” gained significant traction among supporters of the election fraud narrative. It was promoted by high-profile figures, including former President Donald Trump and Rudy Giuliani. The film’s allegations contributed to a climate of mistrust and hostility around the election process, leading to actions such as armed individuals monitoring ballot drop boxes.
7. Admissions and Apologies: Several key promoters of the film, including Rudolph W. Giuliani and Fox News, later admitted that they had spread false information about the election. Salem Media Group issued a public apology to Mark Andrews and removed the film from its platforms. The apology acknowledged the harm caused by the false depiction and the unfounded allegations made in the film.
8. Public Perception and Misinformation: Despite the admissions of falsehoods by some of its promoters and the lack of evidence supporting its claims, many Americans continue to believe the 2020 election was rigged. A poll conducted by CNN in August 2023 found that more than two-thirds of Republican voters did not believe that Joe Biden had won the election fairly. This highlights the enduring impact of misinformation and the challenges in correcting false narratives.
Debate/Essay Questions
- How can society rebuild trust in the electoral process after significant misinformation campaigns?
- How should the balance be struck between protecting free speech and preventing defamation? Should there be stricter laws governing false claims made in the media?
- Despite admissions of falsehoods by promoters of “2000 Mules,” many Americans still believe the election was rigged. What does this indicate about the challenges of correcting misinformation?
- What specific skills and knowledge should be taught to students to help them discern credible sources from false information?
- What criteria should individuals use to evaluate the credibility of sources when consuming news and documentary content?
Please subscribe to Insight Fortnight, our biweekly newsletter!